|
|
Wednesday, February 7

Hurricane Stan: One Year+ On
by
Patrick
on Wed 07 Feb 2007 07:57 PM GMT
Post by Rosemary Burnett

Photo: Rosemary Burnett Don Pedro
stands stiffly to attention outside his makeshift tented house, a
survivor of the mudslide which engulfed the small community of
Panabaj in Guatemala in October 2005. In a way, he was one of the
lucky ones - only one of his five children perished in the wave of
mud and boulders which buried some 600 people as they slept. Sadly,
his thirteen year old son ran back to get his savings of £4 and
was swept into a partly excavated septic tank and buried alive. Others
lost 11 or 12 members of their family and are standing at the edge of
the exhumation site looking to see whether their loved ones will be
identified amongst the bodies being unearthed. Clothes and
possessions are unearthed by the giant excavating machines, then
gathered by relatives to be buried with their former owners.
Particularly sad are the elderly, who wonder why they survived when
their children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren perished. Initially
it was estimated that 1400 were missing, but this was later
reassessed at 600 as survivors reappeared and today it is reckoned
that about 150 people are still buried beneath 4 metres of mud. The
mudslide hit in the middle of the night, and the forensic
archaeologists are finding family groups huddled together. Detailed
records are taken from the survivors of distinguishing
characteristics of a missing loved one – perhaps a gold tooth,
or a leg broken in infancy. The landscape has changed so much –
what was once a pleasant wooded valley has become a desert of mud and
rocks so that orientation of the houses is difficult and the
relatives are often unable to give clear directions as to the
distances between them. In the confusion of that night, it is
sometimes hard to remember which child was sleeping where. Sometimes
a child is found swept downstream and far from his or her own home. Visitors
from overseas can see at a glance that donations from overseas have
provided all sorts of emergency necessities for the survivors.
Oxfam’s logo is prominently displayed on the latrines and the
European Union’s stars are stuck to water tanks. Houses are
made of crude wooden frames whose walls are made up of fabric with
the legend “A gift from the people of the United States of
America”. But the fact remains that more than a year after the
event, people are still living in temporary accommodation, though
infrastructure such as roads and bridges have been repaired. Yet after
Hurricane Stan, money poured in to Guatemala, most notably from the
Spanish government. Why are people still living in temporary
shelters? The government have actually built new breeze block homes,
but they have built them on land which was subjected to a similar mud
slide in the 1950s. Families want to live somewhere safe where a
tidal wave of mud will not carry away their loved ones. Just after
I left Panabaj, on 8 th January, 38 bodies were buried.
The Mayan people have a remarkable resilience when it comes to
dealing with death. They believe that the spirits of their dead will
watch over them and give them guidance in their lives. It is
important to maintain a dialogue with the departed, and every Monday
families go to the graveyard to light candles and honour the spirits
of their ancestors. At least now, the families of the 38 victims will
have a grave to visit. Update (16-02-2007)This from CERIGUA: "La Comisión de Reconstrucción del municipio de Santiago Atitlán, Sololá, agradeció la labor de la Fundación de Antropología Forense (FAFG) por la exhumación de 106 de las víctimas que quedaron sepultadas durante el paso de la tormenta Stan en el Cantón Panabaj, en octubre de 2005."
Update (26-02-2007) This from Siglo XXI which says according to NGO Accion Ciudadana, the Guatemalan government hasn't finished any housing for families affected by Stan- with 80% of the affected families still living in temporary accommodation: Hasta la fecha, cuando han transcurrido casi 16 meses de la tormenta Stan, el Gobierno no ha entregado viviendas a las 7,911 familias que la perdieron durante la emergencia.
El 80% de los daminificados, unas 6,328 familias, sigue en albergues temporales con problemas de hacinamiento y sin servicios esenciales, como agua potable y electricidad, entre otros.
El restante 20% (unas 1,583 familias) debió refugiarse con parientes o alquilar sitios para vivir, según Acción Ciudadana (AC), entidad que se ha encargado de fiscalizar el plan de Reconstrucción Nacional.
"Al día de hoy, no han concluido una sola vivienda. Nos preocupa que 80% sigue en albergues, en condiciones infrahumanas", afirmó Roberto Landaverry, coordinador del programa de Transparencia y Auditoría Social de la Reconstrucción, de AC. Se buscó la postura de Eduardo Aguirre, gerente de Reconstrucción, pero no contestó las llamadas en su teléfono celular. El Gobierno ha prometido que el plan estará terminado en julio.
This article was originally printed in The Big Issue Scotland
Tuesday, January 30

The Outsider: The Line Between Curiosity and Learning
by
Patrick
on Tue 30 Jan 2007 09:16 AM GMT
 A makeshift marker sits some ten feet above a home where a family died during a mudslide caused by Hurricane Stan in 2005. Photo: Xeni Jardin Associated Press reported on the excavation in Panabaj of 100 bodies buried in the landslide caused by Hurricane Stan in 2005. There was a line in the report that touched on an issue that's not usually discussed: "During one such ceremony on Saturday, dozens of mourners wept in front of several coffins, as curious tourists snapped photos of the funeral."
A simple search on Flickr brings up a number of photos taken of Panabaj (although probably not from this particular ceremony). Not to judge these particular photos, but this line about 'curious tourists' touches on an important issue that outsiders* must grapple with. To be sure, there's a very fine line between informative reporting and intrusive disrespectful recording, between wanting to learn, and satiating curiosity. It's a line that as outsiders we're not always on the right side of. When I worked in and around the municipal rubbish dump in Guatemala City, I remember the huge quantity of tourists that would come, usually remain on the coach they came in, and take hundreds of photos of the people who lived and worked amongst the refuse. This type of 'social tourism' is abject. There's a secondary point here. It's so often the case that people from outside of Guatemala are usually either exposed to two contrasting images of Guatemala- one is the touristic colour and natural beauty, and the other is the dark and ugly violence. On the outside as we are on this blog, despite years of commitment and living in the country, it's a constant concern that we avoid simply satiating curiosity and that we manage to go beyond the simplistic outside perceptions of Guatemala. Anyway, this is a massive issue and one we'll be returning to shortly.
* I use the term 'outsider' loosely, it could refer to non-Guatemalans, Guatemalans living outside Guatemala or even Guatemalans from the capital visiting the 'interior'.
Friday, December 22

Rights Action: Hurricane Stan Relief and Rebuilding Work in Guatemala
by
Patrick
on Fri 22 Dec 2006 07:59 PM GMT
It's now just over a year that Hurricane Stan struck Guatemala. What follows is an excerpt from the latest Rights Action newsletter (Dec, 2006) and gives an update on relief work that has been going on to support the rebuilding effort across the country. You can see the full newsletter here. We have been working closely with Rights Action from the UK and there is more information at the end of this post if you are interested in supporting their work. In other news, you can find an article on water privitization, development and human rights violations: Xalala Dam Project= Chixoy Dam revisited. There is also an article on mines, development and human rights violations: Skye Resources Inc and Security Forces versus Mayan-Q’eqchi Communities [ see full newsletter].
Many thanks to all donors - individual and institutional - for your financial contributions over the past year, dating back to October 2005, for our emergency short-term relief and medium-term community rebuilding work in Guatemala in response to the deaths and destruction caused by Hurricane Stan. The 'relief' part of the work is over and the 'rebuilding' work continues; in some regions, it has barely started. In early October 2005, Hurricane Stan devastated much of Guatemala, particularly the western highlands and ‘boca costa’ mountainsides leading down to the south-west pacific coast. The number of persons killed or disappeared is over 2000. It is still not known how many villagers were killed when mudslides buried the villages of Panabaj (departament of Sololá) and Piedra Grande (departamento of San Marcos). At the writing of this report, the FAFG (the Forensic Anthropology Team, long supported by Rights Action to dig up mass graves of genocide and repression victims across the country) has initiated a massive exhumation process in the village of Panabaj where most of the village, and hundreds of villagers, were crushed in a mud-slide. Throughout Guatemala, over 600 villages were negatively affected, to one degree or another; thousands of homes (mainly small huts) were destroyed. SHORT-TERM EMERGENCY RELIEFImmediately after Stan hit, Rights Action appealed for donations and began channelling emergency grants for deliveries of emergency food and water, bedding and clothing, and medical attention. Coordinated from our Guatemala City office, this work was done with numerous community-based groups that we have long supported and worked with. The short-term emergency relief phase lasted into early January! We sent out a summary report early in 2006. VISION OF WORKAs we have written, it is RA’s understanding that while Stan was a devastating storm of torrential rains (resulting in floods, mud-slides, etc), the underlying issue to be addressed is the eradication of endemic poverty (caused by an unjust development- economic model) that leaves a majority of Central Americans subsisting in conditions of great vulnerability. Starting in early 2006, Rights Action began channelling relief grants to medium-term relief and community reconstruction projects that we summarize here. While there is, in these projects, a continuing component of emergency material relief, the main thrust of this work is to re-build, or (in some cases) relocate and rebuild healthy and safe living communities. All of the work summarized below is based on an ‘integral community development vision’, with integrated components of: - Community design of, control over and participation in the reconstruction and rebuilding project - Integral vision of ‘development’, including protection of the local environment, including water sources, and reforesting steep hill and mountains sides - Prioritizing clear title to and community and family ownership of lands - Implementing productive projects that prioritize community and local food security and local and regional markets PROJECTS FUNDED- funds granted and spent, short-term emergency relief phase : $110,000; - funds granted, to date, medium- and long-term rebuilding phase : $500,000; - further funding is needed – long-term rebuilding proposal available on request. PARTNER GROUPS1 - CCDA – COMITE CAMPESINO POR EL DESARROLLO DEL ALTIPLANO / CAMPESINO COMMITTEE FOR DEVELOPMENT IN THE HIGHLANDS For many years, RA has supported and worked with CCDA on a range of community development projects, including production and selling of fair trade coffee. In response to Stan, CCDA is working directly in Mayan-Tzutujil communities of the department of Solola, and Mayan-Mam communities of the department of San Marcos . The main focuses of this work are: - planting and replanting organic coffee that they will sell via their international trading relations for fair trade coffee; - planting and replanting basic subsistence crops of corn and beans. 2 - ASECSA - ASOCIACIÓN DE SERVICIOS COMUNITARIOS DE SALUD/ ASSOCIATION OF COMMUNITY HEALTH SERVICES RA has long supported and worked with ASECSA – a leading community health/dental/ midwifery organization - on a range of community health projects. In response to Stan, ASECSA is supporting the design and building of “granjas integrales” (integral farms) in Mayan-Quiche communities of Tziamjuyub, Pakoval II and Xeabaj II, in the municipality of Santa Catarina Ixtahuacan, department of Solola. 3 - CODECA - COMITE DE DESARROLLO CAMPESINO / CAMPESINO DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE RA has long supported and worked with CODECA on community development and human rights issues in various departments of the south-coastal and Boca Coast regions. In response to Stan, CODECA is designing and supporting projects in 3 communities: - In the Mayan community (a mixture of Quiche, Mam, Kakchikel, Tzutujil, ladino) of Monsenor Romero (105 families; department of Suchitepequez) , CODECA is developing a 5-tank Tilapia fish farm, as well as the reproduction of their staple crops – corn and sesame - In the camepsino community of Rancho Alegre (280 families; municipality of Mazatenango, department of Retalhuleu), CODECA is developing two community projects : a milk cow project and a watermelon and bamboo production project, as well as the re-production of their traditional corn and sesame crops - In the campesino community of Nueva Linda (department of Retalhuleu), CODECA is developing a craft and agricultural production project. 4 - AGEMA - ASOCIACIÓN DE DESARROLLO INTEGRAL Y SALUD COMUNITARIO “GENERACION DEL MAIZ” / ASSOCIATION OF INTEGRAL DEVELOPMENT AND COMMUNITY HEALTH “GENERATION OF CORN” RA began working with and supporting AGEMA, in response to Stan. In the municipality of Santa Catarina Ixtahuacan (department of Solola), AGEMA is working with a new community of some 100 families of a total of some 405 families from 8 different communities that lost homes, land and crops (corn,beans, coffee) to Stan. The communities were : Xoljá, Pacutamá sector I, Pacutamá sector II, Chajuab, Chiucutamá, Pacorral I, Pacorral II, Tzamjuyup and Xeabaj II. For months, these families were in temporary shelters supported by government and non-government (including Rights Action) funding sources. A new living community is being built called “Nuevo Asentamiento Chiquizis”. There are three components to this work : providing “techo minimo” – supplies to build minimal housing structures with simple but sturdy walls and roof; planting a variety of fruit trees (Apples, Cherries, Peaches, y Avacados); building and planting 3 community gardens. 5 - CLINICA MAXENA RA begain working with the Clinica Maxena (that has a long term relation with ASECSA) in response to Stan, in the municipality of Santo Tomas la Union , department of Suchitepequez. The integral health Clinica Maxena is working in the Mayan-Quiche communities of Pala and Patzaj to build community and family gardens. FUTURE PLANS – REBUILDING AND RECONSTRUCTING AFTER STANUpon request, Rights Action can send a proposal “Rebuilding and Reconstructing after Stan” setting out our future and on-going reconstruction and rebuilding plans. TAX-CHARITABLE DONATIONSTo make tax-charitable donations for “Rebuilding and Reconstructing After Stan”: - Credit card donations can be made going to www.rightsaction.org - In the UK contact Jane Pelly de Jocolt at: rightsactionuk [at] yahoo [dot] co [dot] uk
Monday, November 6

Project Information Ixtahuacan: Using The Web in Guatemala
by
Patrick
on Mon 06 Nov 2006 05:58 PM GMT
We've just been contacted by a really interesting initiative called Project Information Ixtahuacan. It uses the internet to improve communication in the new resettled communities following the effects of Hurricane Stan in October 2005. It is really important to be able to see where work is taking place, and where more work needs to be carried out. This is short description of the project taken from the website: "Project Information Ixtahuacan was founded to share information on the projects being carried out in the 9 resettlement communities in the municipality of Santa Catarina Ixtahuacan, Sololá, Guatemala. These communities were relocated in the weeks following tropical storm Stan in October, 2005.
This project is designed to help facilitate better communication as well as improve information sharing between the municipality, the communities, as well as local and international organizations that work in the area. In these pages one can access information on each of the communities such as their location, logistical data, contact information, information on past, present, and planned projects including the organizations that are carrying out these projects.
By compiling this information and making it accessible via this website we hope to create a clearer picture for all those who are working in the area, for those who are planning to do so, as well as other interested parties.
We collect our data from the community committees directly, the municipality of Santa Catarina Ixtahuacan and we integrate the data sent to us from organizations participating in our information sharing project."
Wednesday, October 4

Hurricane Stan One Year On
by
Patrick
on Wed 04 Oct 2006 11:18 PM BST
It's been one year since Hurricane Stan struck Guatemala and much of Central America. The following article by Elizabeth Sagastume called "One year after Hurricane Stan: a silent emergency", has been published on the UN World Food Programme's website. Topline stats are (according to the UN Food Programme): * At least 4,800 families still living in temporary shelters * About 20,000 families still receiving direct food aid from WFP * A further 40,000 helped by food-for-work programmes * In total, some 79,000 families - or 400,000 people - given food aid by the WFP in the past year * About 1.5m Guatemalans directly affected by Stan
There are one or two articles in the Guatemalan press (see below) about the progress since Stan, e.g. Government has only completed 66% of work planned. There is also some coverage on the BBC that's worth reading with information about the current situation in Guatemala one year on. There are more links after the article below: On 5th October 2005, Hurricane Stan raged across Guatemala leaving a trail of destruction in its wake. Its consequences have since become one of the many silent emergencies around the world, writes WFP's Elizabeth Sagastume.
One year ago, Jaime Velasquez Bautista managed to save his eldest daughter but lost his wife in the midst of the fury unleashed by Hurricane Stan.
Jaime is just one of the many people whose lives were ripped apart by Stan in the department of San Marcos – 280 kilometres west of Guatemala City - one of the hardest-hit areas. In Jaime's hometown, Dolores Providencia, 72 people died and more than 600 were left homeless.
Hard on every level
"Losing a loved one and part or all of what you have worked for is very sad. It has been very hard to overcome the economic, physical and emotional problems," says Jaime when WFP visited him in the family shelters where he is living along with his five children, with whom he shares the same bed.
It has provided food assistance to his family and more than 285,000 vulnerable people in 1,500 communities across the effected area since the start of the emergency.
WFP rations
A family of five members receives a monthly ration of 87 kilogrammes of food (60kg of maize, 15kg of corn soy blend, 9kg of beans, 3kg of vegetable oil) intended to provide the 2,120 kilocalorie minimum nutritional requirement for one person.
One year after Stan, the damage it inflicted is still visible but its consequences have become one of the many silent emergencies around the world.
WFP needs US$4 million to continue providing food assistance until February 2007 to help survivors get back on their feet.
Toughing it out
Twelve months afterwards, and despite all government efforts, Jaime and his children are still in a precarious situation but they make the most of it.
"We are living in a shelter and even if it is very small, people like me are grateful to have somewhere to live," he says.
"It has been hard raising my children alone but I have tried to keep them in school," says Jaime.
In the meantime he has managed to find different jobs, earning some money through carpentry and plumbing. He has also borrowed a car so he can deliver messages and provide a taxi service.
But none of these jobs offer financial security nor provide enough money to keep his family.
Jaime is used to working the land, but to do so now requires him to leave his family for a month at a time as people in the highlands have little access to land.
Instead he prefers to stay with his children, but this means they must all live in a temporary shelter and depend on food aid.
Hope dying
People are still waiting for land on which they can build new houses.
"We have been told to wait and be patient but people like me, who have lost everything, are starting to lose hope," says Jaime while perched on top of a rock in the place where his house once stood before the disaster struck.
Even though one year has passed, Jaime believes he can find a solution for his family because he and his community have vowed to keep fighting, working and collaborating to accomplish what they want.
"We continue to make the best of everyday and we hope that we can soon try to rebuild a new life together with our children," he says.
Here's another article from El Periodico about Panabaj- one year on. There's also another interesting look in Spanish on the BBC Mundo website called " Stan: Sus Reacciones". The report also includes video and photos of those affected talking about their experiences. The following article was in the latest weekly report from the Comisión de Derechos Humanos de Guatemala: "Diócesis de San Marcos criticó informe de gobierno sobre reconstrucción post Stan
La Pastoral de la Diócesis de San Marcos criticó el informe del Gobierno, que revela que se ha avanzado el 66% en la reconstrucción del país, sin embargo no ha atendido las necesidades más urgentes de la población afectada por la tormenta Stan en octubre de 2005.
De acuerdo con un diagnóstico de la entidad, el estado cuenta con información incompleta sobre los daños provocados hace un año, como el golpe a la economía campesina, que no figura en los estudios oficiales; tampoco se incluye la infraestructura social, como salones comunales, alcaldías auxiliares e iglesias, ni se considera el impacto en las cuencas, en la vialidad y puentes de la región.
Los registros del gobierno no incluyen el total de viviendas destruidas por el meteoro, mientras que los costos para la construcción de nuevas casas aparentemente han sido sobrevalorados; no se contempla la compra de terrenos para cultivo, sino que predomina la urbanización, a pesar de la característica agrícola de San Marcos, indica el análisis de la Diócesis.
A finales de junio de 2006 el gobierno reportó un avance del 47% en la reconstrucción, en este departamento, sin embargo a mediados de agosto sólo se había logrado el 34%, como lo ha corroborado la Pastoral Social. Por su parte, la Coordinadora Nacional de Organizaciones Campesinas (CNOC), aseguró en un comunicado de prensa que decenas de comunidades marquenses, de Sololá, Quetzaltenango, Retalhuleu, Escuintla y Chimaltenango no han recibido apoyo.
Esta situación demuestra que el gobierno se ha despreocupado por atender las verdaderas necesidades de la población, quienes sufrieron las consecuencias de Stan, pues únicamente ha privilegiado a los sectores que simpatizan con la actual administración, indica el documento.
La CNOC se pregunta cuál es el destino de los fondos donados por la cooperación internacional para la reconstrucción y qué pasará con las miles de familias que aún esperan la asistencia, no sólo material sino del tejido social, según consta en el documento citado.
El 03.10.06, Eduardo Aguirre, gerente de Reconstrucción y el Vicepresidente Eduardo Stein presentaron el cuarto informe de reconstrucción tras el paso del huracán Stan, en octubre del 2005, sin embargo el problema de vivienda es el que más atraso ha afrontado y de hecho, no será este año, sino a mediados de 2007, cuando la mayor parte de damnificados empiece a ver resultados.
Aguirre, informo que serán creados 87 nuevos centros urbanos, a donde se trasladarán las dos mil 800 familias que aún permanecen en albergues.
El informe revela que se han invertido Q1,600 millones, se han recuperado los mil 493 kilómetros de carreteras, se reconstruyeron 712 escuelas, se trabaja en la habilitación de 52 centros de Salud y se han entregado cuatro mil estufas mejoradas y tres mil 492 filtros de agua.
Rafael Estrada, del Comité de Verificación de la Reconstrucción de Santiago Atitlán, Sololá, cuestionó que a un año del paso de Stan en el cantón Panabaj no se haya construido la mayor cantidad de viviendas. Indicó que hay más de 700 familias que todavía no tienen dónde vivir; 200 están en albergues y el resto, alquilando o pidiendo posada en otras casas. Esto se debe agilizar, porque se dijo que Panabaj sería el modelo de la reconstrucción, recordó Estrada."
Thursday, June 22

UK Press Review: Guatemala Facing Latest Storms
by
Patrick
on Thu 22 Jun 2006 11:34 PM BST
There were a few articles this week about the deteriotating weather conditions in Guatemala, Reuters AlertNet reported on the waves battering Guatemala's coast and on the increasing rain fall. As did the BBC and The Guardian.
Thursday, May 25

Stan's Legacy Continues To Be Food Insecurity
by
Patrick
on Thu 25 May 2006 11:36 PM BST
The Mesoamerican Food Security Early Warning System
has recently (15-05-2006) published an update on the current food
security situation in Guatemala since Hurricane Stan. The information
from MFSEWS makes special reference to the XVIII Central American
Climate Outlook Forum held in Belize from April 18-21, 2006.
This has led the National Institute of Seismology, Volcanology, Meteorology, and Hydrology (INSIVUMEH)
to warn in its latest report (24-05-2006) that above normal cyclonic
activity is 80% more likely in the Atlantic region in 2006.
In particular, the current concerns include that the planting of this
year's crops will be affected by lack of suitable drained land for this
purpose. A worry is also the high cost of fuel and relative high cost
of basic food stuffs. In the UK, the plight of Guatemalans more than
six months on from Stan has been picked up by AlertNet and to a lesser extent The Guardian.
Wednesday, May 17

Video: The Full Force of Stan is Still Being Felt
by
Patrick
on Wed 17 May 2006 02:13 AM BST
With winter (our summer) approaching in Guatemala, many of the
communities affected by Hurricane Stan in October 2005 are worried that
the work of rebuilding is going too slowly. Articles are starting to appear in the Guatemalan press that reinforce this worry that communities are still all too vulnerable to winter flooding.
Recently the following video was posted on the internet by guatemalago.org of what it was
like in Panajachel when Stan struck last year. The pictures are very
sobering, and help bring home to those who were not there, what it was
like for those Guatemalans who felt the full force of the hurricane and
its consequences.
Thursday, April 20

Guatemala: Coming to terms with Stan #3
by
Patrick
on Thu 20 Apr 2006 01:15 PM BST
Heather Parr was in Guatemala as Hurricane Stan struck in October 2005. Here she shares her account of how the local community she has got to know in Sololá has undertaken the task of rebuilding their lives and their future.
MoSTANcilla currently consists of 13 groups of 5-7 women who were all made homeless by Stan. Every Monday and Friday afternoon they come to drop off and get paid for the work they have done and pick up their beds for the next week. As the groups are generally friendship groups or family it is also quite a social occasion. Of course the youngest children come too. Some of the late teens attend school in the afternoon, so they come in the morning instead so as not to miss out on their education.
Many women have a limited variety of styles so we have arranged classes where women are paid to share their expertise with others in the group. In the last class 32 women participated. We have been establishing rules for quality control and for fair payment of the women. We are currently paying a rate per item, with the idea being to share the profit fairly amongst the women on a quarterly basis. The first profit share is in March.
The main concern for us right now is to ensure a sustainable market. We have had some success in placing the products in hotels in the city and Antigua, and individuals and organizations such as Miracles in Action have supported out work by giving us a trial order. I am also trying to establish the tax rules for importing into the UK- any experience that you might have to share in this respect would be very welcome! We are also in the process of designing a website to exhibit the ladies’ designs online. The future plan is to establish an official cooperative association and to ensure our accounts are kept carefully, so that after two years we can apply for Fair Trade accreditation.
We are also looking for an interested volunteer who maybe interested in working with the cooperative for a minimum of 6 months (although a year would be preferable) starting in July 2006. This would suit a Hispanic studies student with an interest in fashion and design who aspires to work in sales and marketing in the future.
It will be many years before this population recovers from the destruction that was caused by STAN. However in the meantime we hope that MoSTANcilla can play a small part in the replacement of material goods, and by providing employment and a support network for this particular group of women in the psychological recovery process.
For information you can visit Heather’s blog
Or for further information about reconstruction work in Atitlan since Stan
Wednesday, April 19

Guatemala: Coming to terms with Stan #2
by
Patrick
on Wed 19 Apr 2006 01:10 PM BST
Heather Parr was in Guatemala as Hurricane Stan struck in October 2005. Here she shares her account of how the local community she has got to know in Sololá has undertaken the task of rebuilding their lives and their future.
Over the next three weeks we help 150 men get back to work. At this stage the town hall also starts to give out tools, so we switch our focus to the women knowing that the remaining men are receiving support from other places. The women either weave or make beaded jewelry or ‘mostacilla’ as it is known in Spanish. A local hotel owner is coordinating a project with funding from ECO and Oxfam for the weavers so we concentrate on the bead makers.
The same day that we take this decision in mid November, I hear that my ex pupils at Monkseaton Comnunity High School in Whitley Bay have organized a series of fundraising activities and have made £650. We use this money to buy needles, threads, scissors and of course, beads for the affected women.
We invite ten women who we know to be truly affected to invite five other friends or members of their family who are affected to form a group. Word gets around and we end up with 88 ladies, many of whom are new widows, teenage orphans and all of whom have lost their houses and suffered trauma. Their stories are incredibly moving. It is our intention to simply give them the ‘mostacilla’ so they can start back at work again. But John Bound from www.gypsyrose.com a wholesale trader in the States seeks me out and tells us that he wants to buy directly from the women. He makes a generous donation and more importantly makes me think: what if I could help the women access direct sales?
I do a bit of investigating and the corresponding maths. The women are often paid as little as 2 quetzales (about 20p) for an hours work once they have paid for their materials. The traders on the other hand, will often make double this when it is sold on. I also discover that many NGOs operating in Guatemala sell Guatemalan produced ‘mostacilla’ to raise money for their development work projects. However for some reason, they do not seem to make the connection that by buying from traders at the lowest possible prices they are exploiting one group of people to benefit another.
Can I raise people’s awareness and convince them to buy at a fairer price from the women direct? In this and by finding other markets to sell directly we could potentially quadruple the women’s earnings. This is the beginning of our association MoSTANcilla.
For information you can visit Heather’s blog
Or for further information about reconstruction work in Atitlan since Stan
Monday, April 17

Guatemala: Coming to terms with Stan #1
by
Patrick
on Mon 17 Apr 2006 01:05 PM BST
Heather Parr was in Guatemala as Hurricane Stan struck in October 2005. Here she shares her account of how the local community she has got to know in Sololá has undertaken the task of rebuilding their lives and their future.
It’s Sunday 2nd October 2005 and I arrive in Santiago de Atitlán, Sololá Guatemala intending to spend three months working as a volunteer.
It starts to rain at about 2pm and doesn’t stop for five days. In this time over 600 people in my new community are killed, and between 3,000 and 4,500 people are made homeless as a result of a devastating landslide in Canton Panabaj. I arrived with Hurricane Stan.
Stan cuts us off for the best part of a week. The phone lines are down, the power is off, the roads are closed, the market is shut and nobody anywhere else knows what is happening to the town. Everyone from every walk of society does what they can to help, whether that’s carrying water, washing dishes, sourcing food, chopping vegetables, or taking bleach to the shelters. I see a polio stricken beggar woman crawl to the town hall and donate 15 quetzales (approx. £1.50). Everyone gives what they have to help the people of their town.
After 3 days the power returns and we try and get word out about what has happened. I write to the BBC on their website, but by the time they arrive – eight days on- and interview me we are old news. The Kashmir earthquake has happened and in comparison, the Stan tragedy doesn’t count as news. I ask friends and family for help knowing that if we don’t even make the news, we can’t expect to receive much aid.
Food starts to get through as the press arrive. The next ten days are spent distributing food, but it is clear that the people are not going to receive much long term. We need to help the people affected by Stan, or the ‘damnificados’ as they are emotively being called, back to work. As we give out one of the last donations of food, we interview the people as to what equipment they need to work. My wonderful friends, family and colleagues come through at the same time and we use the initial donations to buy tools for the men so they can go back to their jobs in the fields.
I give them three tools and offer the fourth on micro credit so that they have what they need to go to work. We maintain the contact in case we manage to get more aid. At the same time an Irish volunteer arrives, also with funds from home and we set to work together to collect information as to who needs what, and as far as possible to monitor who has received what from whom, although this proves difficult. This information means we are able to tell passing tourists what is needed and helps us access funding from German association Probigua and from a generous private British donor.
For information you can visit Heather’s blog
Or for further information about reconstruction work in Atitlan since Stan
Monday, April 10

Support the People of Panimache, Guatemala
by
Patrick
on Mon 10 Apr 2006 12:18 AM BST
Just caught this published on St Margaret's Community website in Teddington, West London: "Each year during Lent the people of St Margarets Roman Catholic Church
parish commit to helping some of the poorest people on our planet. This
year they are supporting the villagers of Panimaché in Guatemala and
children and babies orphaned in Uganda. If you would like to help you
can send a donation to St Margarets RC Church Lenten Project and drop it in at the Parish House opposite St Margarets BR Station."
"According to the UN World Food Program an estimated 285,000 people are
still at risk of severe hunger (after Hurricane Stan) after their subsistence crops and food
reserves were destroyed by the rains and resulting floods and
mudslides. Fields were saturated or slid away down the mountain sides
and many people lost their crops of maize. The export crop of sesame
was destroyed. The heavy rains also affected the coffee crop, bringing
an early harvest and much lower than expected yields. St Margarets
parish has committed to raising £15,000 to assist in rebuilding a small
mountain village called Panimaché in the quiche department of Guatemala
where 109 families have lost their homes. The village is near Lake
Atitlán in the western highlands. During the hurricane mudslides swept
down the mountains burying their homes and the river overflowed
destroying their crops. Fortunately, no one died.
Our support will
enable CAFOD partner Caritas Quiché to work
with the community to rebuild their houses. If the parish raise more
than £15,000 the remainder will go to the International Refugee Trust’s
Children’s Home in Uganda."
"Alternatively you could support one of the many events that are taking place.
- Sunday 23rd April Don Rush will run for the 26th time in the London Marathon
with his long time running partner Rush Yadave. They are grateful for
sponsors in support of the Lenten Project. As two of the ‘evegreens’
they will get to start with the elite runners.
- Saturday, 29th April Grand Jumble Sale — 11am St Margarets Church Hall.
- Saturday, 21st May Family Fun Day — 12.00 onwards.
Thank you for your support and interest."
Wednesday, March 22

UK Govt Provides Assessment Of Guatemalan Situation Post-Stan
by
Patrick
on Wed 22 Mar 2006 01:20 PM GMT
Has
someone from Buckingham being writing letters about Guatemala to their
Conservative MP John Bercow? It's great to see his interest in
Guatemala. He recently asked two questions in as many days in the House
of Commons about the current situation in Guatemala with regards death squads and after hurricane Stan in October 2005.
Here
is part of Gareth Thomas's (Parliamentary Under-Secretary, Department
for International Development) response on the situation in Guatemala
after Stan.
"The most affected parts of the country were the
south coast and the western region where 59,000 people were displaced.
Since October 2005, at least 12,310 families have been given temporary
familial shelters or have been reintegrated into their communities. The
Guatemalan Government have undertaken extensive surveys of potential
new land for these communities to minimise future risk of exposure to
floods and mud-slides.
A key reconstruction
priority was ensuring access to safe reliable water, and much of the
rehabilitation effort has focused on this. Waterborne disease remains a
risk for affected communities and the Ministry of Health
have been supported in the provision of transportation services, basic
health kits including mosquito nets, and training for communities in
health and nutrition awareness. Overall progress in reconstructing
sanitation units has been slow, which in many cases has only reached 10
per cent. of target so far. However, some areas have benefited from
intensive NGO efforts to ensure safe water, with as many as 10,000
water filters being provided and treatment plants in three
municipalities. The installation of systems has been undertaken in
close conjunction with local government authorities and communities to ensure sustainability. Children
have been badly affected by the hurricane the most, and those who
remain in shelters will continue to receive psychological and
educational support from rehabilitation partners. A continuing concern
is the restoration of the livelihoods of the communities affected,
either through agricultural support to those who returned to their
homes, or through income generation opportunities for those who remain
in shelters or have been relocated. DFID and the Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO)
have been in discussions with the Guatemalan Government to assess how
those worst affected by Stan can begin to rehabilitate their
livelihoods."
Friday, March 3

Stan Update: Work of Development Organisations in Guatemala
by
Patrick
on Fri 03 Mar 2006 10:31 PM GMT
This is a brief post to flag up examples of media coverage for the work of two development organisations who have been working in Guatemala in the aftermath of Hurricane Stan in October 2005.
The first example is from CAFOD who have been involved in various projects through partners on the ground in Guatemala. This is an article published in the Tablet is from CAFOD's Fiona Callister. She makes the interesting point that although here the disaster was forgotten quickly, solidarity has been impressively strong in Guatemala itself crossing the religious divide between Catholics and Protestants.
"For example in the diocese of Jalapa, which contains San Carlos, desperately poor parishioners collected an impressive $20,000 (£11,500) to help those affected by Stan. Even more remarkably, the decision was taken that, although their diocese had been brought to its knees by the hurricane, they would donate the money to another parish which they considered had been worse hit.
This solidarity has been a strong feature of the disaster response, with Churches organising themselves almost immediately to take it in turns to feed those who had lost everything. So the Pentecostal Church would find 100 eggs for breakfast, then the Catholic Church would provide lunch in the shelters and dinner would come courtesy of the Evangelicals.
Miguel Marroquin, the director of Cafod partner FGER Nahuala community radio, which has helped distribute blankets and food, said: “People who are already poor and have suffered themselves have responded one hundred per cent. It is very humbling and inspiring. There is a great sense of solidarity and unity. The age-old religious divisions have been transformed and everyone is pulling together. This is something we must build on.” "
Fiona Callister mentions CAFOD's lenten fundraising- one example is St Margaret's Church, Richmond, in the UK already mentioned on this blog last month. For more information on their 26th March event, see this post.
The other example is an article that appeared in AlertNet on the work of World Emergency Relief in supporting the rebuilding of houses in affected areas of Guatemala.
"WER has released funds to local partner agency, Cosecha Trust, to purchase land and materials to rebuild houses for families who were left homeless in the aftermath of the disaster. These new homes will provide housing for over 100 people in the town of Tecpan."
Wednesday, February 22

UK Central America Solidarity: What's Happened Since Stan?
by
Patrick
on Wed 22 Feb 2006 12:36 AM GMT
We received this news from Bruce Clarke, Chair of the Swindon Ocotal Link, a member of the Nicaragua Solidarity Campaign. Their group went out to Santiago Atitlan in Guatemala following Hurricane Stan in October 2005 as part of a group trip to Central America.
"We are a small group of friends living in Swindon, England, that has built up a very personal and close relationship with Santiago Atitlan in Guatemala over the past 3 or 4 years.
Our intention originally, was to spend eight days relaxing and enjoying the wonderful lake Atitlan and its community, after a two week working tour of our twin town of Ocotal, Nicaragua. However, the news of the Guatemalan disaster arrived over our comfortable evening mealtime. Soon telephones were ringing and we shared what news we had about Hurricane Stan.
Then we had urgent e-mails to and from Juan Ajtzip Alvarado, my friend in the town. With just 6 weeks to go before we were due to arrive, we knew that there was little immediate help we could offer apart from sending out some immediate funds for materials. Our experience of raising support for Nicaragua following Hurricane Mitch helped us concentrate on the long-term, despite the pleas and terrible pictures that were then arriving in the UK.
In the end, we raised $5,000 in 4 weeks. When we arrived, we found Asociaciòn Tikal Atitlan had been active in supporting the bereaved families and providing counselling for the surviving children. Some 100 adults and over 80 children had been lost. Immediately, two amazing women stood out, Dolores and Juanita. They had organised the children and mothers and set up play groups, meetings, crafts and were selling their wares in the market to help the families get back on their feet economically.
We had no hesitation in agreeing to fund these two amazing women for the next year and a half. From their work, we are planning to bring UK and German youth together with Nicaraguan youth in Santiago Atitlan to share experiences, culture and work together with these remarkable people.
It was good to see Oxfam water tanks had been set up, drains were being dug and workers being paid to maintain the refugee camp. The real issue is helping the families to regain some degree of economic autonomy. We visited the site and were shocked at how a strip of mountain had fallen away and created such devastation. They told us the rain just didn't stop and many other mudslides had occurred around the lake.
We were told they had turned away help from the Guatemalan army which, given recent history, was not surprising. They are fiercely independent.
Now, life goes on, the coffee was a good crop, tourism was getting coming back and normality, such as it is, is returning. Yet, we all felt that the town is under just as much threat in the long term from such things as land being bought up for weekend retreats, and a culture of drugs amongst the youth, as it is from future mudslides. More distressing is the slow loss of identity and values of their proud indigenous community.
We are going back soon, we all have day jobs, but collectively we know we can make a difference and in so doing, make a difference to ourselves as well."
Tuesday, January 31

Stan Represented a Crisis in Communications for Western Media
by
Patrick
on Tue 31 Jan 2006 12:13 AM GMT
According to a study by Tom Vesey, head of media analysts Carma International, western self-interest determines whether or not natural and humanitarian disasters earn column inches. "There is a clear link between the volume of reportage and global economic impact of these events. So, while the political subtext determines the timing, level of commitment and story angle, no connection exists between the scale of the disaster and media interest in the story," he says. In an excellent article in The Guardian, David Adam, reports on Vesey's findings:
Hurricanes Katrina and Stan struck within weeks of each other last year, and both killed more than a thousand people. But while Katrina devastated New Orleans, Stan wreaked his havoc in central America, mainly Guatemala. No prizes for guessing then, which storm has been referred to some 3,105 times in UK papers since then, and which a mere 34...
...Vesey's report reserves its strongest condemnation for reporting of the crisis following hurricane Stan: "The hurricane Stanley emergency stands out as the worst indictment of the selfish western approach to humanitarian disasters. There is no obvious significant economic or political interest. Consequently, there is virtually no coverage of any kind beyond the first few days."
It has always been so, says Leonard Doyle, foreign editor at the Independent. "We have an enormous fascination with the US but we're allowed to have that. It's not a judgment on our degree of interest in central America. We can be interested in that too, but perhaps not as much so because it's not as much on our radar."
He adds: "Whether it's true or not, we have an expectation that in Guatemala the houses are built on hills without proper foundations and there's mudslides and all the rest of it. You look away in despair and say this is a tragedy of the developing world. But you do not expect it in the world's superpower, which makes it fascinating."
The report was also covered by Reuters' AlertNet in the UK. You can download the complete study here.
Monday, January 9

A quick review of the UK relief effort after Hurricane Stan
by
Patrick
on Mon 09 Jan 2006 12:38 AM GMT
 What follows is by no means an exhaustive review, but a number of examples of ways in which UK NGOs have been supporting the emergency relief effort in the wake of Hurricane Stan in October 2005. UK Government's response through DFID provided a total of £250,000 of emergency relief to Guatemala and El Salvador after Hurricane Stan. This support was provided through Plan International UK, £103,000 (70 per cent. for Guatemala and 30 per cent. for El Salvador) and through Care International UK, £100,000 for Guatemala, and £50,000 for El Salvador. Rights Action, which now has an office in the UK as well as Canada and the US, has put together an interesting update (08-12-05) on Hurricane Stan after collecting over US$100,000 for their emergency relief fund. Rights Action has been able support a whole network of community organisations across Guatemala involved in the relief effort. Oxfam have been involved in the relief effort providing 13 water tanks in temporary shelters in Solola. An article on the Oxfam website describes some of the experiences of survivors from the worse affected areas in and around Solola. £200,000 has been approved ( £100,000 from CAFOD and £100,000 from Islamic Relief). Of this, £80,000 is being spent on immediate relief and £120,000 is set aside for the longer-term reconstruction and economic and agricultural reactivation. One of CAFOD partners in Guatemala is the partner the Guatemalan Federation of Radio Education (FGER) who have been helping to coordinate the relief effort by radio. CAFOD have written a series of articles on the aftermath of Stan. Christian Aid covered Stan in their round up of current issues in Guatemala today (January 2006). Christian Aid works with 13 partner organisations in Guatemala. Action Aid Guatemala arranged for an additional £40,000 for San Marcos, in particular for food, medecine and clothes in the wake of Stan. Save the Children has distributed more than 21 tons of food rations including rice, beans, oil, and biscuits as well as medicines, blankets and specific items for children including toys and recreational equipment to assist more than 6,000 displaced people in Santiago de Atitlan and San Lucas Toliman. Additional staff members are arriving at shelters to improve health care and create safe play areas for displaced children. The Guatemala Solidarity Network would also like to highlight the individual efforts across the UK to respond to the emergency. These ranged from organising local fundraising events to actually flying out to Central America to lend support to Guatemalan friends and loved ones. Please let us know of any other work of UK NGOs in Guatemala after Stan, we would be happy to include it here.
Monday, October 17

UK Response to Stan: So Far...
by
Patrick
on Mon 17 Oct 2005 09:50 PM BST
Which UK organisations are doing what: where you can donate to in the UK
ActionAid - UK website does not mention at all, but Action Aid Guatemala has an email you can contact
Save the Children - relief effort is being coordinated in the US
Christian Aid - UK website encourages support for its emergency crisis fund
CAFOD - has a notice and a form to donate to this relief effort
SCIAF- Encouraging donations
Red Cross - relief effort is being coordinated in US, though it says the UK has donated £100,000
Oxfam - has news and a form to donate to this relief effort. Oxfam is warning of a potential food crisis in Guatemala in 2006
War on Want - does not mention Stan yet World Emergency Relief - Calling for donations
You can also support Rights Action that works in Guatemala in their Emergency Relief Fund for Guatemala.
There is a moving video appeal online.
DFID - Does not have a single word on Hurricane Stan in its website DEC- Disaster Emergency Committee does not mention Stan either
For a round up of NGO response to Hurricane Stan see AlertNet's summary One World.Net also pulls together news on the response to Stan from across the UK NGOs.
Sunday, October 16

The Forgotten Emergency?
by
Patrick
on Sun 16 Oct 2005 09:51 PM BST
Never before has such an enormous emergency become unnewsworthy so
quickly. It wasn't just the mudslides and flooding in Guatemala that
became a victim of our collective amnesia, so did the food crisis in
Malawi. The fact that this happened quite so fast, has something to do
with the massive earthquake in Pakistan. But one week on, Pakistan too
is slipping down the news agenda. With this unsustainable publicity,
questions are being asked about how we organise emergency relief. Toby
Porter, Emergency Director of Save of Children writes an interesting
article on this in today's Observer.
This sentiment is echoed in much of the US where the coverage has been relatively poor in the wake of Katrina and Rita. "Hurricane Stan and Guatemala, We Hardly Heard About Ya". It is certainly echoed in many many other blogs, e.g. Norajean, Sunny, etc.
In fact, one of the most recent references to Guatemala in the UK (The Guardian)
was as a possible venue for the 400,000 packaged meals that the US
authorities have quarantined due to "mad cow" import regulations.
State
department officials have considered sending the meals to Guatemala,
devastated by mudslides, but the country does not have the vehicles to
transport the pallets.
AlertNet is doing a great job to counter this with its regular reports. For a feature article on the effects of STAN in the latest edition Informe Guatemala from Fundadesc.
I've seen various articles begin to put the death toll as much higher than the 654 that Conred in Guatemala is officially saying. Caritas in Spain is putting the figure at 2,052, the BBC was putting the figure as over a 1,000, while Cananda's CBC put the figure at 1,400 since 8th October.
The Knight Center for Journalism in the Americas has put together an interesting article on journalism's role in the emergency.
Congratulations are due to El Canche for getting CBS (makers of the great US reality show- Survivor Guatemala- sadly you can watch it online) to change its really supportive page linking to organisations, none of whom were involved in the relief operations in Guatemala. Good on ya Canche.
Friday, October 14

Supporting The Relief Effort
by
Patrick
on Fri 14 Oct 2005 10:35 PM BST
The passage of Hurricane Stan across Central America has left Guatemala the worse affected.
Initially,
CONRED, Guatemala’s official disaster reduction network called red
alerts for communties along the pacific coast, but this was later
extended across Guatemala as the extent of flooding and mudslide damage
became apparent.
In the worst cases, whole communities have
been completely wiped out by the flooding and roads have disappeared.
Many ordinary Guatemalans have volunteered to help in the numerous
rescue operations.
The scale of the disaster appears to be a lot
greater than Hurricane Mitch in 1998 where 268 people were killed in
Guatemala. Rights Action have established an emergency relief fund.
Blog de mi Guatemala has pulled together a collection of sites with the latest images of the effects of Stan across Guatemala. More images are on the ACJ (YMCA) in Guatemala.
Saturday, October 8

Stan: Floods in Guatemala
by
Patrick
on Sat 08 Oct 2005 10:36 PM BST
The latest estimates put the total of people killed in Guatemala as high as (1,400 Source: Reuters). These figures have been changing as the full impact of level 1 hurricane Stan is becoming clear. For photos of the recent flooding in Guatemala ( Source: Incidencia Democracia pulled together here). Other photos from Atitlan- one of the worst affected areas.
You can get more information on how Stan has effected many, many different regions across Guatemala from CONRED. You can find more information in Google Earth here.
|
|